Try free →
AgentGrail/baseball/Players/Jim O'Toole

Jim O'Toole Cards

The complete Jim O'Toole checklist: 19 cards — cards spanning 1959–2016, 1 rookie card, 1 autograph.

Median PSA 10 $174.76Raw $30

Data updated August 13, 2026.

Find Raw Cards on eBayFind PSA 10s on eBay
As an eBay Partner, AgentGrail may be compensated when you click through.

Frequently Asked Questions about Jim O'Toole Cards

Does Jim O'Toole have a rookie card?
Yes. The AgentGrail catalog includes 1 Jim O'Toole rookie card across this set. Rookie cards are among the most sought-after Baseball cards for collectors and investors.
What years were Jim O'Toole cards made?
The AgentGrail catalog includes Jim O'Toole cards from 1959 through 2016, totaling 19 cards across all sets and brands. The earliest cards date from 1959 and the most recent are from 2016.
How much is a Jim O'Toole card worth?
Recent eBay comps show Jim O'Toole PSA 10 cards selling for around $174.76 on average. Raw copies typically sell for around $30.00. Values vary by year, set, and condition. Always check recent sold listings for current pricing.
Are there Jim O'Toole autograph cards?
Yes. The catalog includes 1 Jim O'Toole autograph card. Autographed cards are typically the most valuable Jim O'Toole cards in a set and can command significant premiums in graded condition.
What sets include Jim O'Toole cards?
Jim O'Toole cards appear in numerous sets, including Topps Heritage, Pacific Legends, Topps, and 2 more. The full checklist on this page lists every set in the AgentGrail catalog.
Where can I buy Jim O'Toole cards?
eBay is the largest marketplace for Jim O'Toole baseball cards, offering both raw and graded (PSA, BGS, SGC) copies. Use the "Find on eBay" buttons on this page to search current listings. For investment-grade copies, look for PSA 10 certified cards.

Answers are grounded in AgentGrail catalog data and recent eBay market comps.

More baseball Players

Shohei Ohtani5,888Aaron Judge7,462Ken Griffey Jr.7,835Paul Skenes2,624Jacob Misiorowski1,103Nolan Ryan6,050Mike Trout7,967Bobby Witt Jr.4,063Bo Jackson1,689Derek Jeter4,500Nick Kurtz1,291Konnor Griffin1,273
See all baseball players →

Have a Jim O'Toole card to grade?

Upload a photo and our AI will predict its PSA grade potential in seconds.

Grade My Card Free →

As an eBay Partner, AgentGrail may be compensated when you click through to eBay and complete a purchase. Affiliate revenue does not affect our AI verdicts or pricing — see our methodology.

Predictions on this page are generated by AgentGrail AI and may be inaccurate. Verify any condition or pricing claim before making a purchase decision.

How we identify and grade cards · About AgentGrail

Compiled by the AgentGrail team · Data refreshed August 13, 2026