Nightmare Cards
The complete Nightmare checklist: 5 cards — cards spanning 1993–2023.
Data updated June 16, 2026.
Find Raw Cards on eBayFind PSA 10s on eBayAs an eBay Partner, AgentGrail may be compensated when you click through.As an eBay Partner, AgentGrail may be compensated when you click through.
mtg
2023
Wilds of Eldraine 20231 card
2022
2017
2016
Welcome Deck 2016 20161 card
2015
Magic Origins 20151 card
2014
Magic 2015 20141 card
2013
Magic 2014 20131 card
2009
Magic 2010 20091 card
2007
Tenth Edition 20072 cards
2005
Ninth Edition 20052 cards
2003
8th Edition 20032 cards
Eighth Edition 20032 cards
2001
Seventh Edition 20011 card
Frequently Asked Questions about Nightmare Cards
Does Nightmare have a rookie card?
No confirmed Nightmare rookie cards are currently in the AgentGrail catalog. The catalog covers 5 Nightmare cards in total. Check back as we continue to add new sets.
What years were Nightmare cards made?
The AgentGrail catalog includes Nightmare cards from 1993 through 2023, totaling 5 cards across all sets and brands. The earliest cards date from 1993 and the most recent are from 2023.
What sets include Nightmare cards?
Nightmare cards appear in numerous sets, including Wilds of Eldraine, 30th Anniversary, Welcome Deck 2017, and 2 more. The full checklist on this page lists every set in the AgentGrail catalog.
Where can I buy Nightmare cards?
eBay is the largest marketplace for Nightmare mtg cards, offering both raw and graded (PSA, BGS, SGC) copies. Use the "Find on eBay" buttons on this page to search current listings. For investment-grade copies, look for PSA 10 certified cards.
Answers are grounded in AgentGrail catalog data and recent eBay market comps.
More mtg Players
Island299Forest1,164Swamp273Mountain311Plains299Command Tower165Cultivate81Counterspell80Blasphemous Act72Lightning Greaves68Arcane Signet66Swiftfoot Boots66
See all mtg players →Have a Nightmare card to grade?
Upload a photo and our AI will predict its PSA grade potential in seconds.
Grade My Card Free →Predictions on this page are generated by AgentGrail AI and may be inaccurate. Verify any condition or pricing claim before making a purchase decision.
How we identify and grade cards · About AgentGrail
Compiled by the AgentGrail team · Data refreshed June 16, 2026