1991 Topps Football Checklist

Topps · 1991 · Football · 200 cards across 2 sets

Most Valuable 1991 Topps Football Cards

Phil Simms

#32

$225.00 PSA 10

Dan Marino

#112

$206.00 PSA 10

James Lofton

#43

$162.00 PSA 10

Anthony Munoz

#259

$150.00 PSA 10

Joe Montana

#73

$105.00 PSA 10

Michael Irvin

#368

$100.00 PSA 10

Ranked by AgentGrail Market Value (PSA 10) from recent eBay sold listings. Estimates, not offers. · How we price

Page 1 · Base Set

	#	Player	Team	Flags	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	eBay
	1	Super Bowl XXV			$1.00	$15.00	—	eBay
	5	Ottis Anderson			$2.00	—	$11.00	eBay
	6	Jerry Rice			$2.00	$15.00	$26.00	eBay
	8	Warren Moon			$1.79	—	—	eBay
	10	Receiving Leaders			$1.00	—	$50.00	eBay
	13	Jumbo Elliot			—	—	—	eBay
	15	William Roberts			$1.85	—	$49.99	eBay
	16	Lawrence Taylor			$3.00	$22.00	—	eBay
	18	Rodney Hampton			$1.00	—	$20.00	eBay
	19	Carl Banks			$2.00	—	$30.00	eBay
	26	Mike Fox			$1.00	—	$16.00	eBay
	28	Jeff Hostetler			$1.50	—	$6.44	eBay
	32	Phil Simms			$2.00	$3.00	$225.00	eBay
	36	Jarrod Bunch			$2.00	$15.00	—	eBay
	37	Will Wolford			$2.00	—	—	eBay
	43	James Lofton			$2.00	—	$162.00	eBay
	45	Steve Tasker			$1.49	—	—	eBay
	46	James Williams			—	$9.00	—	eBay
	48	Al Edwards			$1.00	$9.00	—	eBay
	49	Frank Reich			$1.00	—	—	eBay

AgentGrail Market Value — based on recent eBay sold listings and market sales data · updated Jul 10, 2026 · How we price

As an eBay Partner, AgentGrail may be compensated when you click through to eBay and complete a purchase. Affiliate revenue does not affect our AI verdicts or pricing — see our methodology.