1986 Topps Football Checklist

Topps · 1986 · Football · 422 cards across 2 sets

Most Valuable 1986 Topps Football Cards

Reggie White

#275

$4,961.55 PSA 10

Walter Payton

#11

$3,306.00 PSA 10

Dan Marino

#45

$2,150.00 PSA 10

Lawrence Taylor

#151

$1,288.00 PSA 10

Walter Payton

#3

$1,200.00 PSA 10

🃏

Rich Camarillo

#43

$810.00 PSA 10

Ranked by AgentGrail Market Value (PSA 10) from recent eBay sold listings. Estimates, not offers. · How we price

Page 1 · Base Set

	#	Player	Team	Flags	Raw	PSA 9	PSA 10	eBay
	1	Marcus Allen			$1.74	—	—	eBay
	2	Eric Dickerson			$12.50	—	$149.00	eBay
	3	Lionel James	SAN		—	—	—	eBay
	4	Steve Largent	SEA		$1.00	$10.00	$103.00	eBay
	5	George Martin	NYG		$1.78	$19.99	—	eBay
	6	Stephone Paige			$1.00	$23.00	—	eBay
	7	Walter Payton	CHI		$2.43	—	—	eBay
	8	Super Bowl XX - Jim McMahon / Matt Suhey	CHI		$2.00	$87.00	—	eBay
	9	Bears Team Leaders	CHI		—	—	—	eBay
	10	Jim McMahon	CHI		$1,635.00	$35.60	—	eBay
	11	Walter Payton	CHI		$5.62	—	$3,306.00	eBay
	12	Matt Suhey	CHI		$2.00	$85.00	—	eBay
	13	Willie Gault	CHI		$2.00	$80.00	$277.00	eBay
	14	Dennis McKinnon	CHI	RC	$1.00	$10.00	—	eBay
	15	Emery Moorehead	CHI		—	—	—	eBay
	16	Jim Covert	CHI		—	—	—	eBay
	17	Jay Hilgenberg	CHI	RC	$2.54	—	—	eBay
	18	Kevin Butler	CHI	RC	$3.00	$69.00	$252.00	eBay
	19	Richard Dent	CHI		$1.49	—	—	eBay
	20	William Perry	CHI	RC	$29.00	$450.00	—	eBay

AgentGrail Market Value — based on recent eBay sold listings and market sales data · updated Jul 10, 2026 · How we price

As an eBay Partner, AgentGrail may be compensated when you click through to eBay and complete a purchase. Affiliate revenue does not affect our AI verdicts or pricing — see our methodology.